Skip to main content
Customer Service
Call Us (573) 336-7732
our facebook page

Payments & Claims

Many of the carriers that we represent offer a variety of methods for paying your premiums & filing a claim. To make a premium payment for your insurance policy or to file a claim, please find your carrier in the list below and choose the option that suits you best. If you do not see your carrier in the list below or payment link listed for your carrier, please contact us directly. We are always pleased to be of service to you.

Make A Payment

To make a premium payment for your insurance policy, please find your carrier in the list below and choose the payment option that suits you best. If you do not see your carrier in the list below or payment link listed for your carrier, please contact us directly.

File A Claim

To file a new claim, please find your carrier in the list below using the information provided. If you can’t find your carrier or there isn’t a phone number listed, please contact us.

Company Name Payment Link Report A Claim
1st Auto Pay Online 800-261-2886
Allstate Pay Online 800-ALLSTATE
800-255-7828
Barton Mutual 417-843-6265 x 459 417-843-6265 x450
BMI Pay Online 800-310-2717
CFM Pay Online 866-902-4172
Foremost Pay Online 800-527-3907
Grinnell Mutual Pay Online 877-467-2252
Hagerty Pay Online 888-220-9565
Haulers Pay Online 866-665-1003
Hartford Pay Online 800-243-5860
Markel Pay Online 800-362-7535
Missouri Employers Mutual Pay Online 800-442-0593
MutualAid Exchange Pay Online 877-971-6300
Nationwide Pay Online 800-421-3535
Progressive Pay Online 800-776-4737
Safeco Pay Online 800-332-3226
StateAuto Pay Online 877-SA-CLAIM
877-722-5246